Skip to content
GERICLINICS

GeriQBank · Paper III · Q2

A 68-Year-Old with Fracture Neck of Femur — Risk of Further Fragility Fracture, Further Tests and Treatment Options

Moderate YieldAsked ×17-mark note
Chapter
Metabolic Bone Disease & Rheumatology
Years asked
Not recorded in the source
Frequency
Set 1× in Paper III (2009–2025)

As set in the university paper

  • A 68-year-old woman had surgery for fracture of the left neck of femur two months ago and asks whether treatment for osteoporosis will benefit her. What is her risk of another fragility fracture? What further tests would you do and what are her treatment options?

    Paper III · Bone, Joint & Rheumatology · asked ×1 · 7-mark note · see in paper list

Detailed answer

Pro · free in beta
Attempt it firstOutline your answer as a 7-mark note before revealing it — definition, causes, evaluation, management and the geriatric angle.Reveal answer

A. Framing the Problem

1.

A hip fracture after low-energy trauma in a 68-year-old is by definition a fragility fracture and establishes a clinical diagnosis of osteoporosis irrespective of the DXA T-score.

2.

Hip fracture carries substantial excess mortality, loss of independence and institutionalisation; non-hip, non-spine fractures also drive large healthcare utilisation.

B. Risk of a Further Fragility Fracture

3.

A prior fragility fracture is one of the major independent risk factors in Pathy's list — it roughly doubles the risk of any subsequent fracture.

4.

The risk is front-loaded: it is highest in the first 1–2 years after the index fracture — the "imminent fracture risk" window.

5.

Around one in five patients sustains a second fracture, and a substantial proportion of these are contralateral hip fractures.

6.

Yet the treatment gap is wide — most patients leave hospital after a hip fracture without any anti-osteoporosis medication; this is precisely the problem the Fracture Liaison Service was created to solve.

7.

Additional determinants of further fracture in this patient: continuing falls risk, sarcopenia, postural hypotension, visual impairment, polypharmacy (Beers criteria), vitamin D deficiency and post-fall syndrome with fear of falling.

C. Further Tests

8.

DXA of the contralateral hip and lumbar spine — not to decide whether to treat (treatment is already indicated), but to provide a baseline for monitoring and to grade severity.

9.

Lateral thoracolumbar X-ray or VFA to detect silent vertebral fractures, which change risk category and drug choice.

10.

Biochemistry: serum calcium, phosphate, alkaline phosphatase, creatinine/eGFR, full blood count, ESR, 25-OH vitamin D, TSH, liver function.

11.

Targeted secondary-cause screen: PTH, serum and urine protein electrophoresis with free light chains (myeloma), coeliac serology, 24-hour urinary calcium, and in a man morning total testosterone (ng/dL) — late-onset hypogonadism is an under-recognised cause.

12.

Renal function is decisive for drug choice — bisphosphonates are avoided if eGFR is below about 30–35 mL/min.

13.

FRAX with BMD, adjusted for the recent fracture, plus TBS if available, to document the risk category.

14.

Comprehensive geriatric assessment: multifactorial falls assessment, gait and balance testing (Timed Up and Go), cognition, nutrition (MNA), continence, medication review and social circumstances.

D. Treatment Options

(i) Acute and orthogeriatric care

15.

Early surgery (ideally within 48 hours) under a shared orthogeriatric model, multimodal opioid-sparing analgesia including fascia iliaca block, delirium prevention (HELP-type bundle), pressure-ulcer prevention, VTE prophylaxis and early mobilisation with rehabilitation. (ii) Bone-directed pharmacotherapy

16.

Correct vitamin D and calcium first: Pathy's states that all people with a hip fracture should receive calcium, vitamin D and a bisphosphonate unless contraindicated (e.g. renal failure); 25-OH vitamin D should be above 30 ng/mL.

17.

Zoledronic acid 5 mg IV once yearly is the preferred agent after hip fracture — it overcomes adherence problems, reduces clinical fracture by 33%, vertebral by 77% and peripheral by 25%; give at least 2 weeks after vitamin D repletion, ideally ≥2 weeks post-operatively.

18.

Denosumab 60 mg subcutaneously 6-monthly is an alternative, particularly when eGFR is low; monitor calcium and never stop it without bisphosphonate cover.

19.

Anabolic first-line (teriparatide, abaloparatide or romosozumab) if the patient is in the very-high-risk category — hip fracture plus multiple vertebral fractures or very low T-score — followed by an antiresorptive.

20.

Local osteo-enhancement procedure (LOEP) may be considered where hip fracture risk is very high, particularly following a first hip fracture.

21.

Avoid raloxifene and other SERMs after femoral neck fracture — Pathy's is explicit that they do not reduce femoral neck fracture and carry an increased thromboembolic risk in this setting. (iii) Non-pharmacological and systems measures

22.

Falls prevention: progressive strength and balance programme of at least 50 hours, home hazard assessment, footwear, vision correction, withdrawal of culprit drugs (sedatives, antihypertensives, anticholinergics), management of postural hypotension.

23.

Nutrition: protein ≥1 g/kg/day, calcium 1000 mg/day, treatment of sarcopenia by resistance exercise plus protein supplementation.

24.

Hip protectors may be considered in the institutionalised, though adherence is poor, particularly with cognitive impairment.

25.

Enrol in a Fracture Liaison Service with structured follow-up at 3–6 months for adherence, and repeat DXA in 1–3 years.

Latest Updates (2023 – Present)

Imminent fracture risk is now formally recognised (ASBMR/BHOF 2024): the 2 years after a hip fracture constitute the highest-risk period, justifying immediate initiation of potent therapy rather than a "wait for DXA" approach. Goal-directed therapy supports anabolic-first sequencing after hip fracture in those with very low T-scores, since romosozumab→denosumab achieves a T-score above −2.5 far more often than alendronate alone. Registry and meta-analytic data continue to show that early zoledronic acid after hip fracture reduces both re-fracture and all-cause mortality, and that in-hospital initiation markedly improves uptake compared with deferring to primary care.

Fragility Fracture Network / FLS models are now endorsed in Indian practice; NPHCE district-level geriatric units and AB-PMJAY/Ayushman Vay Vandana Card cover hip fracture surgery and follow-up in those ≥70 years.

Current Practice Update

Issue Pathy's position Current position

When to start drug After a fragility fracture, with calcium, vitamin D Same, but started before discharge; deferral to outpatient therapy and a bisphosphonate review is a recognised failure point Drug choice after Bisphosphonate unless contraindicated IV zoledronate preferred; anabolic-first if very high risk hip fracture SERMs Avoid after femoral neck fracture Unchanged — contraindicated in this scenario Exam One-Liners A fragility fracture diagnoses osteoporosis clinically — do not wait for DXA to treat. Highest re-fracture risk is in the first 2 years (imminent risk).

IV zoledronate after hip fracture reduces re-fracture and mortality.

Never give a SERM after a femoral neck fracture.

The Fracture Liaison Service closes the treatment gap.

How was your recall?

Rating marks the question complete. “Need another pass” also adds it to your bookmarks.

References

Spotted an error or something out of date?Report a problem with this page