GeriQBank · Paper III · Q3
Metabolic acidosis
- Chapter
- Nephrology & Acid–Base
- Years asked
- Not recorded in the source
- Frequency
- Set 1× in Paper III (2009–2025)
As set in the university paper
Metabolic acidosis.
Paper III · Renal, Fluid & Electrolyte Disorders · asked ×1 · 7-mark note · see in paper list
Answer framework
- Definition and compensation
- Classification by anion gap — high gap (MUDPILES); normal gap
- Geriatric physiology — delayed peak acid excretion
- Common causes in older adults; the mixed hyperglycaemic state
- Clinical features and chronic consequences
- Investigations
- Management — treat the cause; when to give bicarbonate; dialysis
- Recent updates — KDIGO 2024 threshold; VALOR-CKD and BiCARB; dietary alkali; balanced crystalloids
- Exam traps — albumin correction; reflex bicarbonate; delta-delta
An exam answer plan drawn from the detailed answer below. Use it to attempt the question first.
Detailed answer
Pro · free in betaAttempt it firstOutline your answer as a 7-mark note before revealing it — definition, causes, evaluation, management and the geriatric angle.Reveal answer
Short revision answer
- Metabolic acidosis is a primary fall in bicarbonate (normal 22–26 mEq/L) with falling pH, compensated by hyperventilation — pCO2 falls about 1.2 mmHg per 1 mEq/L bicarbonate fall (Winter's: expected pCO2 = 1.5 × HCO3 + 8 ± 2).
- Anion gap = Na − (Cl + HCO3), normally 8–12 mEq/L. High gap (MUDPILES): methanol, uraemia, DKA, paraldehyde, iron/isoniazid, lactic acidosis, ethylene glycol, salicylates. Normal gap (hyperchloraemic): diarrhoea, RTA, carbonic anhydrase inhibitors, ureteric diversion, large-volume 0.9% saline. Correct the gap for low albumin (add 2.5 per 1 g/dL below 4) — near-universal in the frail.
- Older kidneys reach peak acid excretion at 6–8 hours instead of 4, so the elderly handle acid loads poorly despite normal baseline excretion.
- Common causes in old age: AKI and CKD, sepsis, shock and dehydration (lactate), diarrhoea, DKA and mixed hyperglycaemic states, metformin lactic acidosis, and heat stroke (with respiratory alkalosis). Older diabetics often have a "mixed" state — glucose 270–450 mg/dL, pH 7.2–7.3, without marked dehydration or coma.
- Features are masked: Kussmaul breathing, anorexia, vomiting, weakness, hypotension, hyperkalaemic arrhythmia, and often delirium (it can even mimic depression). Chronic acidosis worsens sarcopenia, osteoporosis and CKD progression — linking it to falls and fractures.
- Investigate with ABG, electrolytes and anion gap, lactate, ketones, glucose, renal function, and where relevant urine pH and urine anion gap (RTA) and osmolal gap (toxic alcohols); use the delta-delta check for a coexisting normal-gap acidosis or alkalosis.
- Treat the cause, not the number: restore perfusion in lactic acidosis, insulin and fluids in DKA, stop metformin, relieve obstruction or dialyse in AKI, treat sepsis. Bicarbonate only for severe acidaemia (pH below about 7.1) or hyperkalaemia, cautiously (sodium load, heart failure, hypokalaemia, hypocalcaemia); dialysis for refractory acidosis and when GFR is below 10 mL/min.
- Updates: KDIGO 2024 makes alkali a practice point when bicarbonate is <18 mEq/L; veverimer failed in VALOR-CKD (1480 patients; only ~1 mEq/L separation); BiCARB in over-60s with mild acidosis showed no benefit, higher cost and worse quality of life; a 2024 meta-analysis found bicarbonate helps kidney function and muscle but raises BP — so in frail older adults favour dietary alkali (fruit and vegetables) and observation; use balanced crystalloids for large-volume resuscitation.
Condensed by GeriClinics from the detailed answer below, with no new facts added.
7 MARKS
Metabolic acidosis
High-Yield Points
Definition: a primary fall in serum bicarbonate with a fall in blood pH, compensated by hyperventilation and a fall in pCO₂. Normal bicarbonate is 22–26 mEq/L; expected compensation is a fall in pCO₂ of about 1.2 mmHg for every 1 mEq/L fall in bicarbonate.
Classification is by anion gap = Na+ − (Cl− + HCO₃−), normally 8–12 mEq/L. High anion gap (added acid) — MUDPILES: Methanol, Uraemia, Diabetic ketoacidosis, Paraldehyde, Iron/Isoniazid, Lactic acidosis, Ethylene glycol, Salicylates. Normal anion gap (hyperchloraemic, bicarbonate loss): diarrhoea, renal tubular acidosis, carbonic anhydrase inhibitors, ureteric diversion, large-volume 0.9% saline.
Key geriatric physiology: older people take longer to reach peak proton excretion. After an acid load, maximal ammonia and titratable acid excretion is reached in 4 hours in the young but only at 6–8 hours in the old, so the elderly have greater difficulty handling states of acidosis even though their baseline acid excretion is normal.
Common causes in older adults: acute kidney injury and chronic kidney disease (retained acid and uraemia); sepsis, shock and dehydration (lactic acidosis); diarrhoea; diabetic ketoacidosis and mixed hyperglycaemic states; drugs, especially metformin-induced lactic acidosis; heat stroke, which causes metabolic acidosis with respiratory alkalosis.
A characteristic geriatric presentation is the "mixed" metabolic disturbance of older diabetics — neither classical ketoacidosis nor hyperosmolar coma, with glucose around 270–450 mg/dL, arterial pH 7.2–7.3 (not markedly acidotic), and without marked dehydration or altered consciousness.
Clinical features are often masked in the elderly: Kussmaul breathing, anorexia, vomiting, weakness, hypotension and arrhythmia from hyperkalaemia, and frequently delirium as the presenting feature. Acid–base disturbance is also a recognised metabolic cause of apparent depression in old age.
Chronic acidosis has geriatric consequences: muscle protein catabolism worsening sarcopenia, bone demineralisation worsening osteoporosis, and accelerated CKD progression — linking it directly to falls and fracture risk.
Investigations: arterial blood gas, electrolytes with calculated anion gap, serum bicarbonate, lactate, ketones, glucose, urea and creatinine, and where relevant urine pH and urine anion gap (for renal tubular acidosis) and osmolal gap (for toxic alcohols).
Management principle is to treat the cause, not the number: volume resuscitation and restoration of perfusion for lactic acidosis, insulin with fluids for ketoacidosis, withdrawal of metformin, relief of obstruction or dialysis in AKI, and treatment of sepsis.
Sodium bicarbonate is reserved for severe acidaemia (pH below about 7.1) or for associated hyperkalaemia. Use it cautiously in the elderly — the sodium load can precipitate heart failure and hypertension, and it can cause hypokalaemia, hypocalcaemia and volume overload. In advanced CKD, dialysis is indicated for refractory acidosis, and replacement therapy is needed when GFR falls below 10 mL/min.
Latest Updates (2023–Present) — Condensed
KDIGO 2024 CKD guideline downgraded alkali therapy to a practice point, suggesting treatment be considered when serum bicarbonate is below 18 mEq/L, rather than routinely correcting all mild acidosis. VALOR-CKD (JASN 2024) — veverimer, a non-absorbed gastrointestinal hydrochloric acid binder, did not slow CKD progression in 1480 patients (eGFR 20–40 mL/min/1.73 m², bicarbonate 12–20 mEq/L), largely because only about 1 mEq/L of bicarbonate separation was achieved. The earlier BiCARB trial in patients over 60 with low-grade acidosis likewise showed no clinical benefit, higher cost and lower quality of life.
A 2024 CJASN meta-analysis found sodium bicarbonate improves kidney function and mid-arm muscle circumference but raises systolic blood pressure — so in frail older adults with mild acidosis the balance now favours dietary alkali (fruit and vegetables, low potential renal acid load) and careful observation over reflex bicarbonate prescribing.
Current Practice Update
Issue Textbook position Current evidence (2023–2026)
Alkali in CKD Correct acidosis to maintain bicarbonate in the Treat when bicarbonate <18 mEq/L; a practice normal range point, not a strong recommendation Novel agents Sodium bicarbonate is the mainstay Veverimer failed in VALOR-CKD; sodium bicarbonate remains the only practical option, plus dietary alkali Older adults Correction assumed beneficial BiCARB showed no benefit and possible harm in over-60s with mild acidosis; watch sodium load and blood pressure Resuscitation fluid 0.9% saline for volume repletion Balanced crystalloids preferred for large volumes, to avoid iatrogenic hyperchloraemic acidosis Exam One-Liners Anion gap = Na − (Cl + HCO₃); normal 8–12 mEq/L.
Expected pCO₂ = 1.5 × HCO₃ + 8 ± 2 (Winter's formula).
The elderly reach peak acid excretion at 6–8 hours instead of 4.
Metformin → high anion gap lactic acidosis; heat stroke → metabolic acidosis with respiratory alkalosis. Chronic acidosis drives sarcopenia and bone demineralisation.
Bicarbonate therapy threshold in CKD is now <18 mEq/L.
Examiner Traps
Calculating the anion gap but forgetting to correct for albumin (add 2.5 mEq/L for every 1 g/dL fall below 4 g/dL) — hypoalbuminaemia is near-universal in frail elderly and masks a raised gap.
Giving bicarbonate reflexively in lactic acidosis instead of restoring perfusion.
Missing the delta-delta check for a coexisting normal-gap acidosis or metabolic alkalosis (common with vomiting or diuretics).
Forgetting that delirium may be the only presenting sign in an older patient.
If Asked as a 15-Mark Question, Expand With
Detailed physiology of renal acid handling (bicarbonate reabsorption in the proximal tubule, titratable acid and ammoniagenesis distally) • full classification table of high vs normal anion gap causes with the delta-delta ratio • the four types of renal tubular acidosis with their urine pH, potassium and stone associations • systemic effects of acidaemia organ by organ (cardiac contractility, arrhythmia, catecholamine resistance, insulin resistance, hyperkalaemia, bone buffering, protein catabolism) • the geriatric consequences chain: acidosis → sarcopenia + osteoporosis → falls and fracture • specific management protocols for diabetic ketoacidosis and hyperosmolar states in the elderly, with slower fluid rates and closer attention to cardiac and cognitive status • renal replacement therapy indications (AEIOU) • the 2023–2026 evidence block above.
How was your recall?
Rating marks the question complete. “Need another pass” also adds it to your bookmarks.
References
- PAPERS-2-3-4_COMBINED.pdf — page 771
- GeriQBank source PDF — p. 771
Spotted an error or something out of date?Report a problem with this page